Services
StrategyPlans, positioning, leadership›GrowthAds, search, email, social›Creative and webBrand, websites, content, video›OperationsHubSpot and revenue operations›Property marketingRendering to signed lease›Creative and web
All services →Strategy, creative and execution, all in house.
See pricing →Every channel, one team, weekly results.
See pricing →Work that ships weekly and looks like you.
See pricing →Every channel, one team, weekly results.
See pricing →Different buildings. Same obsession with leases.
See pricing →Industries
Real EstateIndustrial, commercial, residential›SaaS and technologyHR tech, EdTech, FinTech, PropTech›Home servicesHVAC, roofing, plumbing, electrical›Professional servicesLaw, accounting, advisors, recruiting›VC and private equityPortfolio and fund marketing›Real estate marketing
Overview →Services for every building
SaaS and technology marketing
Overview →Who we work with
What we run for them
Home services marketing
Who we work with
What we run for them
Professional services marketing
Overview →Who we work with
What we run for them
Different buildings. Same obsession with leases.
Pricing and packages →Different products. Same obsession with pipeline.
All SaaS and technology work →Different trades. Same obsession with booked jobs.
All home services work →Different practices. Same obsession with signed clients.
All professional services work →Company
About usThe team behind LeapynHow we workWeekly delivery, one teamWhy LeapynWhat we mean by differentCase studiesResults with the numbersContactSay helloMarketing that earns its keep.
Book a call →Learn what is working before you spend on it.
All insights →Services
Marketing strategy
Growth marketing
Paid advertising
Creative and web
Operations
Property marketing
Industries
Real estate marketing
Services−Company
Marketing strategy
40% of businesses plan to switch marketing agencies. Here's the evaluation framework, the red flags, and the questions to ask before signing anything.

In this post
40%. That is the share of businesses that industry research reported by Ad Age found were planning to switch marketing agencies. Nearly half cited delivery issues as the primary reason they ended their last agency relationship. Gartner's CMO research on agency partnerships reaches the same conclusion from a different angle. Agency churn is consistently driven by a delivery gap, not a pricing gap.
Most of those relationships started with a pitch that looked credible. A polished deck. Case studies. A senior person in the room. The problem is not that agencies are universally dishonest. It is that the standard process for choosing a marketing agency rewards people who are good at pitching, not people who are good at delivering. What follows is the evaluation framework to run before signing anything, the questions polished agencies cannot prepare for, and how Leapyn answers its own criteria.
Six criteria separate agencies worth hiring from agencies worth avoiding.
Four patterns consistently appear in agency relationships that disappoint.
Starting with a defined 90-day pilot rather than a full long-term commitment is the structural protection the standard selection process consistently fails to provide. The pilot works only if three conditions are defined before day one.
A defined deliverables list before day one. The pilot should begin with a written document specifying exactly what will be produced in 90 days. That includes which campaigns, which content pieces, and which reports at which frequency. Any scope change during the pilot should require written agreement from both parties. An agency that resists defining deliverables upfront has already decided it will not be held to them.
A measurable checkpoint at day 30. Not a final result, but a signal review. Are the initial campaigns structured correctly? Is the tracking infrastructure in place? Are communications happening at the promised cadence? If the checkpoint reveals a significant problem, name it directly, get a written remediation plan with a 14-day correction window, and use what happens next as the actual evaluation. How an agency responds to a problem at day 30 is more informative than how it responded to a question in the pitch.
A clear off-ramp condition. Before the pilot starts, define what would cause you to end it at 90 days and what the operational exit looks like. Asset access, campaign pausing, and data handover procedures should all be documented before work begins, not negotiated under pressure at the end of a relationship that has either succeeded or failed. An agency confident in its work has no reason to resist documenting this.
The questions in any agency's prepared presentation are the ones they rehearsed. These are the ones they did not.
"Who specifically will work on my account day-to-day after we sign?" A credible answer includes full names, LinkedIn profiles, and the account-to-team-member ratio. A deflective answer is "our team" or "we staff appropriately to client needs."
"Can I have admin access to all my ad accounts and analytics from day one?" A credible answer is yes, with a specific process for how it is set up before work begins. A red flag is "we manage those centrally" or "we will set that up once we are underway."
"What is your fee structure and does any part of it change if my ad spend goes up or down?" This is the diagnostic for percentage-of-spend pricing. A credible answer is a fixed fee clearly unrelated to budget size. A red flag is "we charge a management percentage on top of media spend."
"Tell me about a campaign that significantly underperformed and what you did about it." A credible answer names a specific campaign, a specific metric, a specific intervention, and an honest outcome. A deflective answer pivots to successes or frames everything as a learning without specifics.
"What data would you need from me before recommending a strategy?" A credible answer asks about customer acquisition cost targets, gross margins, average deal value, current close rate, and sales cycle length. A deflective answer asks about brand and aesthetic preferences.
"Can I speak to three current clients I choose from your published client list, rather than three you select for me?" Most credible agencies will agree. Resistance to this request is informative.
"What happens to my campaigns, assets, and data if we stop working together?" A credible answer is full handover, all access retained by the client, and a documented exit procedure. A deflective answer involves vague language about transition support or extended notice requirements before accessing assets the client owns.
"What would make this engagement unsuccessful, and what do you do when that happens?" A credible answer defines failure specifically, names an escalation process, and describes the conditions under which the agency would recommend stopping. A deflective answer is "we do not let engagements fail" or an immediate pivot to confidence statements.
Four framework rules appear frequently in marketing research and buyer education. Each is useful as an agency evaluation diagnostic because a knowledgeable agency should be able to apply them to a specific client situation, not just recite them.
The 7-11-4 Rule. A buyer typically needs about 7 hours of content engagement, 11 touchpoints, and encounters across 4 different platforms or locations before purchase intent becomes strong enough to act on. This framework is grounded in Google's research on buyer trust and purchase behaviour. Ask a prospective agency whether they have applied this to a client's content and channel strategy. An agency that plans around individual campaign conversions without accounting for the full trust-building journey will consistently underestimate the time and touchpoints required to convert a cold audience.
The 3-3-3 Rule. In a sales and marketing context, the 3-3-3 principle suggests reviewing three pieces of relevant context about a prospect, spending three minutes on preparation, and making contact within three business days of a buying signal. Applied as an agency evaluation question, it reveals whether the agency integrates sales signals with marketing activity or treats marketing and sales as entirely separate programs. Ask how they handle the moment when a content-engaged prospect shows purchase intent.
The 3-7-27 Rule of Branding. The rule holds that a brand makes an initial impression in 3 seconds, is remembered after roughly 7 interactions, and builds genuine trust after around 27 interactions. The specific numbers are a heuristic rather than a rigorously sourced empirical finding, but the underlying principle is well-supported by research on repeated exposure and brand recognition. Ask a prospective agency how they plan for the trust-building timeline across your specific brand. An agency that plans only for the first impression is not planning for the relationship that produces a commercial outcome.
The 1% Rule. On most platforms, roughly 1% of users create content, 9% engage with it, and 90% consume it without visible interaction. Applied as a content strategy diagnostic, this rule reveals whether the agency understands the difference between activating internal experts and producing brand content on company accounts. Ask how they think about developing thought leadership from people inside the business. An agency that defaults to managing your company social accounts rather than activating your internal experts is running a broadcast publishing model.
Applying the same framework to ourselves is the only honest way to close a post like this. If the criteria above are worth asking another agency, they are worth asking Leapyn.
| Evaluation Criterion | Leapyn's Answer | Where to Verify |
|---|---|---|
| Own Your Assets | All ad accounts and platform assets are transferred to client admin access before any campaign launches. No agency-owned accounts. | leapyn.com/how-we-work |
| Transparent Reporting | Weekly sprint delivery with direct platform access. Reporting tied to pipeline and qualified leads, not impressions or follower count. | leapyn.com/how-we-work |
| Bait and Switch Avoidance | Small, intentional client roster. The strategist in your free strategy session is the person running your account after you sign. | leapyn.com/why-leapyn |
| Demand Data | The free strategy session starts with customer acquisition cost targets, deal value, close rate, and business goals before any channel recommendation. | leapyn.com/free-strategy-session |
| Real References | The client roster is intentionally small. Current clients are available to speak with on request. | leapyn.com/case-studies |
| Failed Campaign Process | Weekly retrospectives are built into the sprint model. Underperforming campaigns are identified and adapted within days, not months. | leapyn.com/how-we-work |
Your email for great content delivered to your inbox. Regularly. Unless we forget. Or get busy. But we'll try.
Vetting-based selection reveals an agency's actual operating model before you have committed budget to discovering it the hard way. The criteria exist not to make the process harder but to make the outcome more predictable. An agency that is genuinely good at what it does will answer every question in this post with specific, named, verifiable information.
If you want to run this evaluation against Leapyn specifically, the free strategy session is where that conversation starts. Bring the questions. We will answer them directly.
“
The first call felt like talking to someone who already understood our business. We didn’t have to explain the basics. They showed up with questions that mattered.
James L.
Director of Growth, HR tech
Client
Carlos V.
FAQ
Paid advertising typically shows initial signal within 30 to 60 days, enough data to know whether the targeting and creative are directionally correct but not enough to declare success or failure. SEO takes 6 to 12 months for meaningful organic traction. Email and content nurturing programs typically show engagement signals within 60 to 90 days and pipeline impact within 3 to 6 months. The distinction worth drawing is between a results checkpoint (what signal should exist by this date) and a results guarantee (which no credible agency will offer). Define the checkpoints before you sign.
For SMBs and mid-market companies, marketing agency retainers typically start around $1,500 to $2,000 per month at entry level and rise into the $3,000 to $10,000 or more range depending on channel mix, content volume, and how much senior strategic attention is included. The main cost drivers are whether paid media management is included, content production volume, and reporting depth. Leapyn's pricing page shows how we structure engagements.
Specialist agencies offer deeper expertise in one channel. A paid media specialist knows Google Ads at a depth a generalist may not. Full-service agencies offer integrated strategy where each channel reinforces the others, and the messaging is consistent across email, content, paid, and SEO rather than disconnected across separate vendors. The right choice depends on whether the marketing problem is a specific channel problem or a whole-program problem. How Leapyn compares to the traditional agency model is worth reading if you are evaluating both options.
Three signals are the clearest indicators. First, the reporting you receive measures opens, impressions, and traffic but cannot connect any of that activity to qualified leads or closed revenue. Second, the team running your campaigns has changed without a direct conversation about why. Third, you have asked a direct question about campaign performance and received an answer that explains the metrics without explaining the outcome. Any one of these is worth raising directly with the agency. All three together is a clear recommendation to run a formal evaluation.
Stay updated
Keep reading